The Diplomacy of Temperament

Last updated:

Hasty judgments can give way to genuine encounters if we are aware of our own perspective and that of others. A reflection on language, freedom, and human encounters through the lens of temperament.


A conversation begins before opinions meet: in the encounter of two rhythms. One person has found the words; the other is still trying to make sense of what is happening. They may want the same outcome and yet fail to meet. Judgement can come quickly. To the quicker person, the other seems blocked; to the one who needs time, the first seems superficial. These are often simply different ways in which the ‘I’, the soul, and the world come together.

The four temperaments do not “explain” a person. They tell us how we approach the world, not who we are. They name forces that color perception, feeling, memory, and will. In conversation, two kinds of attention are also speaking. From an anthroposophical perspective, temperament does not coincide with the ‘I’. It belongs to the constitution through which the ‘I’ enters earthly life, bringing inclinations, resistances, and gifts. Forgetting this leads to: “This is simply how I am.” Inner work is then reduced to a label.

Change begins before any technique. Observing a force at work in oneself without identifying with it opens a space between impulse and action, where a reaction can cease to be automatic. What interests me is recognizing when my temperament is at work: in what I notice and overlook, in my judgements, and in my words. This is evident in my work. Knowing my colleagues well is helpful, but it can make me less attentive. I expect a reaction before it occurs. Sometimes I am actually right; then the automatism is even harder to see. There is a paradox here. In creative work the new is expected, and yet we must resist the habit of seeing only what we already know.

The Language of Temperament

Two people may be discussing a subject, yet two rhythms are often in conflict. One feels it is time to decide; the other feels that something is missing. For the first, the question is settled; for the second, it has yet to become clear. What one experiences as delay, the other experiences as pressure. Temperament is useful when it shows not who is right, but how each person has arrived at what they take to be true. A Goethean habit can enhance conversation: first see, then name. Let what is at issue appear before confining it within a concept; listen before answering. We usually do the opposite: we interpret while the other speaks, classify before something has shown itself, and prepare our answer while listening.

A word spoken too early can prevent reality from showing itself. “It is like this ….” can be knowledge or a closed door. The same happens between people: “You are always like this” or “I already know what you mean.” An image takes the place of the other person. The language of temperament can have the same effect. If I say, “You are choleric,” that definition may anticipate your every gesture and predetermine its meaning. The concept that was meant to help me see now stands between me and you. If this tendency is interrupted, something else can begin. I see one thing, you another; if we stay within our own view, two worlds remain side by side. But the matter itself can take shape between us. This is not compromise: it is a richer reality, seen by two people.

Dialogue can reveal what neither person could have seen alone. Sometimes a question is enough; sometimes silence gives a thought form. Here lies the difference between dialogue and persuasion. In persuasion the idea is complete and remains only to be communicated. In dialogue I may arrive with a strong conviction and let the encounter change the way I hold it. I need not abandon what I take to be true, but I may have to abandon the thought that my way of saying it is the only possible form of that truth. Listening means allowing what the other sees to work upon my thinking. The hardest exercise is to give back the other’s thought, before disagreeing, in a form they can recognize and agree to rather than in the version easiest to attack. This seems obvious, but it requires me to distinguish my reaction from what has actually been said.

Inclinations

Waldorf pedagogy offers a useful indication: temperament is not merely something to overcome; its force must be guided towards what can integrate it. With adults, this work concerns ourselves first. Asking what technique to use with the other person is already close to manipulation. With my two-year-old daughter it is different. Her temperament is still forming, and I cannot rely on a fixed image of her. This keeps me open to what she brings. The difficulty is to not anticipate her choice but to wait until what she wants can show itself. At her age, the will exists before it can be understood, by her or by us. With adults, by contrast, we stop waiting because we believe that we already know. The question is not what to do with the other person, but what quality to develop in myself so that the relationship can become freer. This quality is evident in the way we respond: moving immediately to the next image is a sanguine trait; closing towards a direction, a choleric one; keeping experience within, a phlegmatic one; allowing the past to weigh on the present, a melancholic one. These are not four kinds of people, but inclinations seen before they are named.

In the sanguine temperament attention moves quickly: one image calls forth the next. This can be openness, but it can also mean naming the world before it has appeared. What it requires is not slowness, but continuity: remaining with one thing.

The choleric has a strong will and seeks a direction at once when faced with an obstacle. This can be courage; but what they see may become entangled with what they want to happen. The task is not to weaken this force, but to make it firm without creating opposition.

The phlegmatic preserves continuity. They are not moved by every novelty, but this strength can become delay. Experience remains inside, without passing from perception to speech and responsibility. What is needed is not external pressure but inner movement.

In the melancholic, what others let pass remains and becomes memory. From this comes loyalty. But the past can determine how the present is seen before the new has truly been looked at. The weight must be acknowledged, without allowing suffering to become the measure of every experience.

These are not instruments for managing the other person but what the relationship requires of us. Knowledge of temperament becomes self-education. It can, however, become control. If I learn another person’s rhythm to anticipate their reaction, avoid their resistance, or lead them where I want, I may be skillful, but I do not make them freer. I merely get around them.

Diplomacy

Words carry a moral weight. A question can open a space or lead towards an answer already chosen. If I want to persuade, I judge the outcome; if I want an encounter, I accept that it may remain open. There is a freedom before speech. We think of the right to say what we wish; there is also the freedom not to say at once all that arises in us. A breath, a question before judgement, refusing to complete the sentence already prepared while the other was speaking: these may be enough. That pause is the point at which the ‘I’ can become present. This is an everyday diplomacy: in the family, at work, in love. One person must speak at once; the other needs silence. Silence feels like distance, speaking like pressure. Perhaps neither is rejecting the other: they are trying to repair the same relationship through opposite movements. In a meeting the same pattern occurs. One person wants to decide after a few minutes; the other still brings elements they consider necessary. If they remain enclosed in their own rhythm, the discussion becomes personal. If the rhythm becomes visible, something can change.

Temperament does not resolve conflict. It can make it legible and weaken the idea that our own way of resolving a question is simply the natural one. Diplomacy does not mean avoiding conflict, but creating a space in which it can exist without destroying understanding. An honest disagreement is sometimes truer than an agreement reached too quickly. Difference forms us, because another rhythm calls for qualities that our own temperament does not provide. Perhaps this is how the pedagogy of temperament enters adult life: not by educating the other person, but by recognizing that an encounter can educate us too, if we do not use knowledge merely to protect ourselves. To educate temperament does not mean eliminating it, but making it less determining, so that a freer response can become possible.

Two people do not meet merely to confirm fully formed worlds. Sometimes they make something between them that neither could have made alone. Often conversation remains two worlds side by side. But when words seek neither to win nor to direct the other, space opens for that other possibility.


Translation From Italian, by the author
Image Steve A Johnson / Unsplash

Letzte Kommentare