Rudolf Steiner collected books, held lectures, and took on responsibilities at the Deutsche Lesehalle [German reading room] in Vienna. But political power struggles and anti-Semitic hostility shook the student association and his work.
Marginalia on Rudolf Steiner’s Life and Work No. 40.
In Chapter XIII of his autobiography, Chapters in the Course of My Life, Rudolf Steiner describes in considerable detail his membership in the German Reading Room student association at the Technical Institute in Vienna, which shows just how significant this activity was for him. He recalls, “At assemblies and smaller gatherings, the political and cultural events of the time were discussed in depth. The discussions brought to light all manner of possible—and impossible—viewpoints that young people might hold.”1
The German Reading Room at the Technical Institute in Vienna
Originally, the association was called the Technical Reading and Debating Hall [Technische Lese- und Redehalle]. But in March 1881, the name was changed to the German Debating Hall [Deutsche Redehalle], “and, certainly, with a nationalist tendency”;2 accordingly, black, red, and gold—the colors of the democratic movement in Germany since the Hambach Festival of 1832—were chosen as the association’s new colors. This emphasis on German nationalism served as a kind of counterpoint to the formation of Prime Minister Eduard von Taaffe’s government in 1879, from which the German Liberal Party was excluded—a move that sparked intense discontent among Austria’s German-speaking population, as they no longer felt adequately represented in the government. This gave the German nationalist movement a strong boost, and it became extremely popular, particularly with students. The German Nationalists initially understood themselves as Greater German liberals but very soon split into several factions; the trend toward anti-Semitism, propagated by Georg von Schönerer (1841–1921), became increasingly prominent. And so, in 1885, the party split into the so-called “anti-Semites” [Antisemiten] and the “Greater Germans” [Grossdeutschen]. But signs of this split had already become apparent earlier within the German Debating Hall. Steiner wrote, “Especially when functionaries were to be elected, opinions clashed quite fiercely. Much of what was taking place among the youth in connection with the events in Austria’s public life was both stimulating and exciting. It was a time when the national parties were taking shape with ever greater intensity. Everything that later led more and more to the disintegration of the empire in Austria—and whose consequences became apparent after the World War—could be experienced in its early stages back then.”3
In 1882, the Reading Room had several hundred members—not only students (350), but also professors, honorary members, donors, etc. The association actively participated in Austria’s political and cultural life, organizing lectures and celebrations—as well as so-called “Kneipen,” that is, social gatherings. Among those serving as trustees were Professors Karl Julius Schröer and Edmund Reitlinger, both of whom Steiner held in high regard; Ferdinand von Hochstetter served as “patron” [Protektor]. Members, who naturally paid a small membership fee, enjoyed discounts at theaters, bathhouses, bookstores, and on purchases of optical equipment. Students had access to the reading room’s impressive library, which contained numerous specialized books and journals. There were also a number of subsections, including a chess club, a fencing club, a stenography club, a music club, and a mathematics and natural science club, among others.4
Until 1881, Steiner was just an ordinary member. Presumably for the 1881–82 academic year, he was then “elected librarian of the reading room”:5 “In that capacity,” as he wrote, “I tracked down all kinds of authors who had written books that I believed might be of value to the student library. I wrote ‘begging letters’ to these authors. I often wrote as many as a hundred such letters in a single week. Thanks to this ‘work’ of mine, the library grew rapidly. But the endeavor had a side effect for me. It gave me the opportunity to become acquainted, to a great extent, with the scientific, artistic, cultural-historical, and political literature of the time. I was an avid reader of the donated books.”6 His fellow students Walter Fehr and Moritz Zitter were also active in the Reading Room—in March 1882, they were elected to the executive committee (Zitter) and as an alternate member (Fehr).7 Steiner’s “desire for social interaction found ample satisfaction in the Reading Room.”8
On one occasion, Steiner also gave a lecture on Fichte to this group, as he recounts in his lecture of July 30, 1921: “And then I was granted the opportunity, as a participant in the German Reading Room at the Vienna Institute, to speak about Johann Gottlieb Fichte to a circle of the Viennese student body. I tried to incorporate into what I wanted to say about Fichte everything that seemed to me—albeit in an immature way at the time—to be necessary for fructifying spiritual life from a very particular perspective.”9
Rudolf Steiner as Obmann of the German Reading Room
When Steiner emphasizes that his interest was awakened “also for wider spheres of public life” “through the reflections of its events in student associational life,”10 he is likely referring primarily to the 1882–83 academic year, when the association was going through a difficult period. A “Germanic party” had formed within the Reading Room, and to belong to it meant professing allegiance to the anti-Semite Georg von Schönerer. Opposing it, as the majority, was the “German National” party. The “Germanic party” then sought more and more to dominate the German Reading Room. As a result, in the autumn of 1882, after “tumultuous proceedings,” three general assemblies had to be closed by the government representative present at each. The rector of the Technical Institute prohibited any further general assemblies from being held on its premises, so the members had to meet elsewhere.
The “Germanic party” was above all opposed to the candidates proposed for the new executive committee. With the statement “We don’t need a Jew as president,”11 they turned against the presidential candidate Viktor Monath. He had declared “that he would always stand up for Germandom and freedom,” but would never “recognize as Germans those who pursue Schönerer’s tendencies.”12 The “Germanic party” also fought Steiner’s candidacy for vice president [Obmann], “because he had put forward the claim that we are Germans not by birth but by culture, through Goethe, Lessing, Kant, Schiller—just as one of the noblest German poets, the author of the Diätetik der Seele [Dietetics of the soul], Baron von Feuchtersleben, was even descended from a Negro13 (in the third generation).”14 After the first assembly was dissolved, the “Germanic party” tried to recruit as many new members as possible through agitation, but it did not succeed in gaining the upper hand. In the end, a compromise was found by granting the “Germanic party” a few members on the committee as well. As planned, Viktor Monath became president, and the “Obmänner” (vice president/chairman and deputy) were “Steiner (German-national) and [Vincenz] Schmidt (Germanic).”15 It was on November 30, 1882, that Steiner was thus elected “Obmann,” that is, “chairman of the Reading Room.”16 These events are echoed in Steiner’s account quoted above.
During the six months that Steiner served as vice president, Richard Wagner died on February 13, 1883. The association’s leadership sent a telegram of condolence to his widow, Cosima: “The German Reading Room at the Technical Institute in Vienna extends its deepest condolences to Your Excellency on the passing of the greatest German composer, to whom we look up with reverence.”17
Steiner recounts his time in a leadership role: “But that was a difficult office for me. For I was confronted with a great number of very different party viewpoints, and I saw that there was some merit to all of them. Nevertheless, members of the various parties came to me. Each wanted to convince me that only their party was right. When I was elected, all the parties voted for me. For up until then, they had only heard how I had stood up for what was right in the assemblies. After I had been chairman for half a year, they all voted against me. For by then they had come to realize that I could not agree with any one party as strongly as they wanted me to.”18 Presumably, in addition to the two major party blocs, many smaller parties with their own aims had also formed.
Newspaper reports give us a closer look at what happened at the time. The “Germanic party” continued to stir up unrest. In March 1883, they again broke up a general assembly; their ringleader, Karl Soyka, was then expelled from the association. Meanwhile, the authorities were even considering dissolving the association. At this point, the executive committee itself proposed dissolution at the plenary assembly of June 7, 1883, chaired by Steiner, as reported in the newspaper Die Presse:
“At the plenary assembly of the German Reading Room at the Technical Institute, held yesterday under the chairmanship of the association’s Obmann, Mr. Steiner, engineering student,19 the only matter discussed was the committee’s motion to dissolve the association. The grounds for this motion are that, as a result of the turbulent events of the last winter semester, most of the Reading Room’s supporting members gave notice of their resignation from the association, depriving it of more than half of its income, and that, moreover, as a result of the quarrels among the members, the statutory purpose of the Reading Room had been almost entirely neglected. In the debate on the committee’s motion, the moderate elements of the association voted in favor of it, while those members who had caused the quarrels in the association declared themselves against dissolution, in the hope of now gaining control of the association. The motion, which would have required a four-fifths majority to pass, therefore remained in the minority. In place of the Obmann and deputy Obmann, who thereupon resigned, Mr. Mauthner, engineering student, was elected Obmann, and Mr. Emil Gärtner, engineering student, deputy Obmann.”20
And so Steiner resigned from his position in June 1883. A month later, the semester ended, and with it his eight-semester course of study at the Technical Institute. The German Reading Room Association continued to weather turbulent times until the situation gradually began to settle down again.
Translation Joshua Kelberman
Image Telegram from the executive committee of the Deutsche Lesehalle at the Technical Institute of Vienna to Cosima Wagner, Vienna, February 15, 1883. Nationalarchiv der Richard-Wagner-Stiftung, Bayreuth, NA IV B 24–3 W No. 8. License: CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Footnotes
- Rudolf Steiner, Autobiography: Chapters in the Course of My Life, CW 28 (Great Barrington, MA: SteinerBooks, 2006), 42. I am grateful to Ralph Machunze, whose valuable indications inspired this marginalia.
- Wiener Allgemeine Zeitung, March 11, 1881, 5.
- Steiner, Autobiography, ibid.
- All of this can be found in the Jahresbericht der Deutschen Lesehalle für das Jahr 1880/81 [Annual report of the German Reading Room for the year 1880/81]. Unfortunately, no such report is available for the following year.
- Since records regarding the German Reading Room from those years are incomplete, it has not yet been possible to determine the exact period during which Rudolf Steiner served as librarian.
- Steiner, Autobiography, ibid. Some books bearing the Reading Room’s stamp can still be found today in Rudolf Steiner’s library; books were regularly removed from the collection.
- Deutsche Hochschule: Organ der deutschen Studentenschaft [German university: Organ of the German student body] (Prague), March 16, 1882, 4. Moritz Zitter (1861–1921), from Sibiu [Hermannstadt], later ran an advertising agency in Vienna and remained in contact with Rudolf Steiner until his death; Walter Fehr (1862–1928) worked as a railway traffic official and eventually as a senior inspector [Oberrevisor] for the Austrian railways. For more on both friends, see Martina Maria Sam, Rudolf Steiner: Kindheit und Jugend [Rudolf Steiner: Childhood and youth] (Dornach: Verlag am Goetheanum, 2018) (on Zitter); and Martina Maria Sam, Rudolf Steiner: Die Wiener Jahre [Rudolf Steiner: The Vienna years] (Dornach: Verlag am Goetheanum, 2021) (on Fehr and Zitter). The architect Oskar Marmorek (1863–1909), a co-organizer of the First Zionist Congress in Basel in 1897, was also on the association’s executive committee. He later married Nelly Schwarz, a pupil of Rudolf Steiner’s who was related to the Specht family.
- Steiner, Autobiography, ibid.
- Rudolf Steiner, Die Aufgabe der Anthroposophie gegenüber Wissenschaft und Leben [The task of anthroposophy in relation to science and life], GA 77a (Dornach: Rudolf Steiner Verlag, 1997), 162, lecture in Darmstadt, July 30, 1921.
- Steiner, Autobiography, ibid.
- Das Vaterland (Vienna), November 16, 1882, 4.
- Münchener Bote für Stadt und Land, November 19, 1882, 1.
- The German word “Neger” and the English word “Negro” are considered racist and discriminatory today, but they reflect the usage of the time and are quoted here purely as a historical source.
- Deutsche Hochschule: Organ der deutschen Studentenschaft [German university: Organ of the German student body] (Prague), December 1, 1882, 5. The first wife of Ernst von Feuchtersleben (1766–1834), father of the physician and writer of the same name (1806–1849), was Josepha Soliman (1772–1801), a daughter of the Afro-Austrian valet and Freemason Angelo Soliman (c. 1721–1796). Only Ernst the younger’s half-brother Eduard (1798–1857), a mining engineer and writer, came from this union, however; Ernst the younger came from his father’s second marriage, to Cäcilie von Clisolis, and had no African ancestry.
- Das Vaterland (Vienna), December 1, 1882, 5.
- Steiner, Autobiography, ibid.
- The text of the telegram was printed in many newspapers, including the Morgen-Post (Vienna), February 16, 1883, 2.
- Steiner, Autobiography, ibid.
- The designation “engineering student” (in the German original, “stud. ing.,” Lat. studiosus ingenieriae, “student of engineering”) is probably a misprint, since Rudolf Steiner was studying in the General Department [Allgemeine Abteilung] and was just then finishing his studies.
- Die Presse (Vienna), no. 155, June 8, 1883, 11.

